Chronology of Border Patrol Use of Force Issues since 2010

Chronology of Border Patrol Use of Force Issues since 2010

1-4-2010

Jorge Solis-Palma was shot and killed by a Border after reportedly throwing a rock and injuring an agent. Fatal Surveillance camera captured the fatal shooting.

Article: Border Patrol Cameras Capture Parts of Incident
Article: AZ Border Agent Cleared in Fatal Shooting

3-31-2010

Victor Santillan de la Cruz was shot and killed during a struggle with a Border Patrol agent.

Article: Man Shot at Border Had History of Illegal Entry
Article: Man Shot by Border Patrol Agent Identified
Article: OIG report – Page 190

4-23-2010

Border Patrol Agent Robert Kipler entered a residence located just south of Van Buren with Main State Trooper during a domestic dispute investigation. The State Trooper and CBP agent fired at the subject, Neil Begin. Begin was struck by some of the rounds and collapsed to the floor. After being transported to a local hospital and then to a hospital in Bangor, Maine, he died the next morning. The AG found the shooting to be justified.

Article: State Trooper, Border Patrol Agent Justified in Fatal Shooting

5-28-2010

Anastasio Hernandez Rojas is tortured to death by over a dozen border agents (CBP and Border Patrol) at San Ysidro port-of-entry in California in view of border travelers. Witnesses video record his cries for help. The video footage is too dark to make out what is taking place, but Hernandez’s cries for help are clear and alarming. Some witnesses had their recording devices confiscated and videos deleted by the U.S. port-of-entry officials. Border Patrol claims Hernandez was combative and uncooperative, requiring use of force. Eyewitnesses claim otherwise. Almost two years later, a new eyewitness video surfaced that supports eyewitnesses accounts (see below).

Watch: Eyewitness video

6-7-2010 

Sergio Adrian Huereca, 15, is shot to death on the U.S.-Mexico border near El Paso, Texas while standing in Mexico. CBP officials claim that the Border Patrol agent was surrounded by a group tossing rocks. An eyewitness video does not support these facts, showing the agent firing shots at individuals who are at a distance and outside the frame of the camera. The agent is also wearing a bicycle helmet. The Department of Justice later dismisses the case due to lack of jurisdiction.

Watch: Eyewitness video

10-5-2010

Juan Mendez, Jr. was shot in the back twice and killed by a Border Patrol agent after being in car chase. Mendez was stopped by the officer for driving with a “suspicious load” and took off running; he briefly struggled with the agent before the shooting.

Article: Deputy: Border Agent Kills Unarmed Suspect
Article: 18 Year Old Eagle Passan Shot and Killed by U.S. Border Patrol 

1-5-2011

Ramses Barron Torres was shot and killed after allegedly throwing rocks at Border Patrol. Witnesses deny he threw rocks. DOJ stated in their press release closing their investigation that they reviewed surveillance videos, but videos have not been released publicly.

Article: Border Shooting Now a Federal Case in Mexico
Press Release: Federal Officials Close the Investigation into the Death of Ramses Barron-Torres

1-13-2011

Roberto Pérez Pérez was beaten while in detention for trying to re-enter the U.S. and died due to lack of proper medical care.

Article: Fallece mexicano que denunció una golpiza
Article: Deadly patrols: Challenges to Prosecution

2-27-2011

Alex Martinez was shot and killed by Border Patrol agents while allegedly swinging a hammer and smashing windows in his mobile home. Martinez had a history of mental problems. His brother says Martinez did not come out running and instead complied with commands to step out of the house. What officers believed to be a gun in his possession was in fact a flashlight.

Article: Man killed in Whatcom County deputy-involved shooting

3-29-2011

U.S. Citizen Carlos La Madrid, 19, was shot four times in the back near Douglas, Arizona. Border Patrol states that someone on a ladder above him was throwing rocks.

Article: Carlos Lamadrid’s Mother, 19-Year-Old Killed By Border Patrol, Sues

4-18-2011

Wheelchair-bound Amado Rodriguez was shot and killed by  members of the El Paso County Sheriff’s SWAT team. The Fabens Border Patrol Station provided back up. The shooting was investigated by the El Paso Sheriff’s Department and Internal Affairs but the results of the investigation have not been released.

Article: Niece of Man Slain in Fabens: He was unarmed.

4-18-2011

An investigation by The Arizona Republic found that since 2005 on-duty Border Patrol agents and Customs and Border Protection officers have killed at least 45 people, including 13 Americans. This database includes details on those 45 deaths, and an additional death involving an off-duty officer. The database is current as of March 25, 2014.

Article: Force at the Border

6-21-2011

Jose Alfredo Yañez Reyes was shot and killed along the fence near the San Ysidro Border Crossing. Agents claim suspected border crossers were throwing rocks; it’s unclear if Reyes was involved in the rock throwing.

Article: ACLU Calls for Probe in Border Shooting

9-13-2011

Culture of Cruelty report is released by Arizona based No More Deaths, revealing thousands of cases of abuse by CBP.

Download: A Culture of Cruelty

9-15-2011

An off-duty CBP agent got into a shootout with his wife’s cousin, Omar Olivares. Olivares was killed on the scene. The agent died later in the hospital.

Article: Force at the Border

10-3-2011

Gerardo Rico Lozano was shot and killed after CBP agents pulled over his vehicle.

Article: Man killed by Border Patrol Agent Identified

12-6-2011

Byron Neftalí Sosa Orellana was shot and killed by a CBP agent after allegedly assaulting the agent and a police dog.

Article: Man Shot By Border Patrol In Arizona Is Identified

3-15-2012

Alexander Arthur Martin died in car explosion that may have been caused by Border Patrol tasers. Border Patrol officials chased Martin’s car after he began driving the wrong way down the highway.

Article: Man Killed Near Old Buckman Springs Road ID’d
Article: Border Explosion Death Investigated as Homicide

4-20-2012

Nearly two years after the killing of Anastasio Hernandez Rojas and after no movement whatsoever by the authorities to investigate the case, PBS airs never before seen eyewitness footage of the beating and killing of Hernandez revealing a man who was detained, hogtied and face down on the ground while agents kicked, punched and Tasered him at least five times until his heart stopped.

Video: Need to Know – Crossing the Line At The Border

5-3-2012

Over nine cities across the country take part in demonstrations demanding justice for Anastasio Hernandez Rojas and border families affected by Border Patrol abuse.

Press Release: Families Affected by Border Brutality Joined By Vigils Across the U.S.

5-10-2012

Maria Luz Rojas, mother of Anastasio Hernandez Rojas, and representatives of the Southern Border Communities Coalition travel to Washington D.C. to deliver a petition signed by over 30,000 people to the Department of Justice asking for investigations into all deaths caused by lethal use-of-force by CBP, and for accountability and oversight.

As a result of this visit, 16 members of Congress write letters to Janet Napolitano (DHS), Inspector General Charles K. Edwards, and Attorney General Eric Holder (DOJ), raising questions about the serious problems stemming from the use of force by U.S. Customs and Border Protection officers and agents.

Press Release: 16 MEMBERS OF CONGRESS CALL FOR JUSTICE IN HERNANDEZ-ROJAS CASE

Documents:
Letter to Janet Napolitano (DHS)
Letter to Inspector General Charles K. Edwards
Letter to Attorney General Eric Holder

6-23-2012

Charles Robinson was shot and killed by U.S. Border Patrol agents during a confrontation at Mr. Robinson’s residence on the Long Pond Road in Jackman.

Press Release: Report of Attorney General William J. Schneider on the Use of Deadly Force by U.S. Border Patrol Agents in Jackman on June 23, 2012

7-9-2012

Juan Pablo Perez Santillan was shot and killed by a CBP agent while standing on the bank of the Rio Grande in Matamoros just across from Brownsville. Border Patrol claims Perez Santillan was throwing rocks. Witnesses say he was unarmed.

Article: U.S. Border Patrol Agent Fatally Shoots Man Across Border

9-3-2012

Guillermo Arévalo Pedroza was shot and killed by CBP agents while on a picnic with his wife and two young daughters on the Mexican side of the Rio Grande. Border patrol agents claim they were under attack from rock throwers. A video posted online by a Nuevo Laredo news organization showed the shooting, but didn’t show any rock throwing.

Video: Elements of the US Border Patrol kill Mexican

10-25-2012

ACLU presents Human Rights Violations on the United States-Mexico Border to the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, which details the alarming trend of abuse and lethal excessive use of force at the hands of CBP officers and agents.

Download: Human Rights Violations on the United States-Mexico Border

7-12-2012

A grand jury announces investigation in the case of Anastasio Hernandez Rojas.

Article: AP NewsBreak – Grand Jury Probes Border Death

9-28-2012

Valeria Munique Tachiquin, U.S. citizen and mother of five, is killed in an urban community by a federal agent serving a warrant for someone else.  The agent, Justin Tackett, had been previously fired from his career as an Imperial County sheriff’s deputy. In a termination letter written by Imperial County Sheriff’s Department Chief Sharon Housouer, Tackett was described as being unfit to carry a badge or a gun due to his history of misconduct.

Watch: 10News.com Investigative Series

Download: Tacket vs. County of Imperial

10-10-2012

José Antonio Elena Rodriguez, 16, is killed while standing in Nogales, Mexico near the U.S.-Mexico border fence in Arizona. Border Patrol claims individuals were throwing rocks. Investigative reports reveal conflicting accounts.

Article: LA Times - Border Patrol shooting of Mexican teen draws condemnation

10-18-2012

The United Nations declares that U.S. uses excessive force along Mexican border. U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights Navi Pillay said that law enforcement officials should use non-violent methods before any forceful action is taken. Pillay calls on the U.S. and Mexico to transparently investigate incidents where lethal force was used. 

Article: http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/10/18/mexico-us-un-rights-idUSL5E8LIK9220121018

12-2-2012

Margarito Lopez Morelos was shot and killed after a struggle with a CBP agent. 

Article: Probe into border shootings draws questions

2-6-2013

According to Government Accountability Reports, the number of border patrol agents has doubled between 2004 to 2012. But a source says that getting into the Border Patrol training academy is easy. The course periods have dropped from 20 weeks to 12 weeks and a couple of requirements have been cut back. Members of Congress question the agency’s accountability. 

Article: Inside sources say Border Patrol agents are a ‘menace to society’.

2-19-2013

SBCC releases Better Border Briefing with recommendations by border communities for improved border policy.

Border Briefing: Why We Need Better Borders, Not More Border Enforcement 

  1. Benchmarks for Border Security Have Been Met. 
  2. Border Communities are Safe. 
  3. Net Unauthorized Migration from Mexico has Fallen to Zero. 
  4. Border Enforcement Costs Billions, Can We Afford More? 
  5. With Crossings at a Historic Low, Apprehensions are Manageable. 
  6. Effecient Ports of Entry Should be the Priority Moving Forward. 
  7. Heartland States Depend on Efficient Ports at the Southern Border. 
  8. The Dangers of Unchecked Border Enforcement. 
  9. A Better Border Begins with Efficiency & Accountability 

Document: http://soboco.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/Border-Briefing-Final-2-8-13.pdf

3-7-2013

Rep. Lucille Roybal-Allard meets with families of victims of Border Patrol brutality. She acknowledges the excessive use of force by border patrol agents and the need to better train these agents. Rep. Roybal-Allard says that these families need to be heard before any new decisions on border enforcement are made.

Press Release: http://soboco.org/?p=919

3-21-2013

Mathew Simmons was shot and killed after agents drove up to his car on the side of the road near Otay Mesa Border. His car appeared to have been in an accident. One of the agents checked the car license place and determined it was a stolen vehicle. Simmons pulled a handgun on the 3 agents, shooting one of them on the him. The agents responded with gunfire and killed him.

Article: CBP Agents Shoot, Kill Carjacking Suspect at Border

6-1-2013

Over the Line : Why are U.S. Border Patrol agents shooting into Mexico and killing innocent civilians? - Washington Monthly article providing an overview of abuse incidents and rock throwing in particular. The article also highlights the problems of rapidly increasing the number of border patrol agents, which results in more inexperienced agents and correlates with the unjustified killings of people by border patrol agents.

Article: Over the Line

6-26-2013

Leaked Border Patrol report expresses dangers of irresponsible enforcement buildup. Oversight and accountability are not being looked into and instead Senate has proposed to increase the number of agents from 20,000 to 45,000.

Press Release: http://soboco.org/border-patrol-report-expresses-dangers-of-irresponsible-enforcement-buildup/

9-17-2013

Office of Inspector General (OIG) releases report – U.S. Customs and Border Protection Use of Force Training and Actions to Address Use of Force Incidents.

Report: http://www.oig.dhs.gov/assets/Mgmt/2013/OIG_13-114_Sep13.pdf

SBCC critiques report as incomplete and insufficient.

9-18-2013

An audit of the Border Patrol training finds that many agents don’t understand the use-of-force-rules. It also found the trainings to be too short and there was a lack of tests given in the comprehension of the use of “less-lethal” force.

LA Times: Many border agents don’t understand use-of-force rules, report says

9-25-2013

CBP web post on Use of Force Reviews, Recommendations and Next Steps (posted on the morning of the Southwest Border Forum, prior to meeting with SBCC).

Post: http://cbp.gov/xp/cgov/border_security/bs/force_reviews.xml

9-27-2013

White House blog post regarding Southwest Border Forum (White House forum held with SBCC and multiple governmental representatives on 9/25/13).

It talks about the Senate bill and ways it could fix the broken immigration system, such as improving the visa processing and giving farm workers an opportunity to gain citizenship.

Post: http://www.whitehouse.gov/blog/2013/09/27/white-house-hosts-southwest-border-economy-and-public-safety-forum

10-19-2013

Ernesto Gutierrez Cortez, a resident in Perris, CA, was fatally shot by a CBP agent at the Otay Border Crossing. Authorities said that Cortez tried to go around the other traffic at the border crossing, then drove towards the Customs and Border Protection officer. That officer and two others opened fire on the car, killing Cortez.

Article: Man shot by feds at border was Perris resident

11-5-2013

CBP reveals Police Executive Review Forum (PERF) report has been issued with recommendations to change use-of-force policy. Border Patrol Chief Mike Fisher states that the Border Patrol will not follow these best police practices recommendations and that the agency will continue to use lethal force.

Article: http://news.yahoo.com/ap-exclusive-border-patrol-rejects-curbs-force-051854692.html

11-14-2013

Article: US Border Patrol has ‘alarming’ alcohol problem, says internal memo and inside source

U.S. Border Patrol Chief Michael Fisher writes a memo about the Border Patrol averaging two alcohol-related arrests a week. An inside source tells of border agents showing up to work drunk and still allowed to work. 

11-18-2013

Cruz Marcelino Velazquez died from drinking a highly concentrated liquid methamphetamine  at the San Diego border crossing. He drank the liquid methamphetamine at the request of CBP agents.

Article: Cruz Marcelino Velazquez Died From Drinking Meth At Border Crossing, Report Confirms

11-20-2013

Border communities send nearly 200 quilt panels expressing stories of loss as a result of border militarization. The Border Quilt is displayed on the National Mall in sight of the Capitol Building.

Press Release: http://soboco.org/?p=1664

11-25-2013

Twenty members of Congress sign a letter addressed to Custom and Border Protections’ Acting Commissioner Thomas Winkowski requesting a meeting to discuss growing concerns about the agency’s lack of accountability and oversight, which has resulted in countless cases of abuse and corruption within the agency.

Letter: http://soboco.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/11/Letter-to-Acting-Commissioner-Winkowski.pdf

12-16-2013

Arizona Republic reports that 42 individuals have been killed by Border Patrol agents since Feb. 2005 and, “In none of the 42 deaths is any agent or officer publicly known to have faced consequences – not from the Border Patrol, not from Customs and Border Protection or Homeland Security, not from the Department of Justice, and not, ultimately, from criminal or civil courts.”

Article: http://www.azcentral.com/news/politics/articles/20131212arizona-border-patrol-deadly-force-investigation.html?nclick_check=1

12-19-2013

ACLU Border Affiliates Sue Feds, Hospital for Invasive Cavity Searches of Woman

A 54-year-old woman was subjected to a strip-search and later taken to the University Medical Center of El Paso for other unjustified examinations that lasted for six hours- all without a warrant. She was then released without charge. The woman, who is a U.S. citizen, was only attempting to cross a bridge in El Paso to return to the U.S. from Mexico when CBP agents stopped her.

Press Release: http://soboco.org/?p=1697

1-2-2014

Border Patrol agent Adam S. Garibay, 33, is suspected of killing his wife’s lover, Keith J. Martin, 35. After beating and tying up his wife in Corpus Christi, Garibay drove to Martin’s home on a private road 3 miles north of Hondo, TX, and allegedly shot him to death.

Article: Border patrol agent suspected in Hondo killing

1-9-2014

USA Today: Numbers don’t back need for lethal force at border

Border Patrol Chief Michael Fisher told The Associated Press that “to say that you shouldn’t shoot at rock-throwers or vehicles, for us, in our environment … could potentially put Border Patrol agents in danger.” But data from Custom and border protection and the FBI proves that local police and sheriff’s deputies are more likely to be assaulted than a Border Patrol agent. The data proves that there needs to be better training for agents and changes to the use-of-force policy. 

1-16-2014

Reportedly, Gabriel Sanchez Velazquez struggled with a Border Patrol agent in an attempt to  get the federal officer’s weapon. The BP agent, ” freaking for his personal safety and potential serious injury, pulled his handgun and fired at the suspect”. Velazquez was struck in the upper boy area and “succumbed to his injuries at the scene. Velazquez was part of a group that Border Patrol was tracking near Apache and Portal, Arizona. He was located by an agent “hiding under a mesquite bush.” Cochise County Sheriff’s Office is leading the investigation.

Article: Mexico Condemns Killing of Migrant in Arizona

1-17-2014

NBC San Diego “Politically Speaking” segment with Shawn Moran, the VP of the national BP union discussing PERF, rock throwing, allegations of abuse.

1-31-2014

Border Patrol staff show children how to shoot with paintball guns at fully-dressed target. The “shooting range” is a few feet from the border fence and a 100 feet from a location where actual people have been killed. This event is not only a symbol of the Border Patrol agency’s violent use-of-force, but it also enforces the obvious need for accountability and oversight of the Border Patrol agency. 

Press Release: Disturbing Images Show Border Agents Encouraging Children to Shoot at Human Effigy

2-10-2014

Jose Guzman, the man who released a cellphone video to 10News of a controversial Border Patrol arrest, was arrested for supposedly violating the terms of CPAC. CPAC arrested him for not contacting his case worker after making contact with the Border Patrol agents. Judge agrees with Guzman’s attorney that there should’ve been an administrative hearing with Guzman by CPAC before the arrest.

Also see: Cellphone video of Border Patrol arrest raises questions of excessive force
Article: Man who shot controversial Border Patrol brutality video fights for release from jail.

2-18-2014

Jesús Flores-Cruz was shot and killed by a Border Patrol agent after Florez-Cruz allegedly hurled several large rocks at him. Investigators said that one of the larger pieces hit the agent in the head and that the agent feared for his life so he fired his weapon.

Article: Mexico Condemns Shooting by U.S. Border Agent

2-19-2014

Deputy Secretary of Homeland Security Alejandro Mayorkas and General Services Administration Administrator Dan Tangherlini visited the Laredo Port of Entry and announced funding to expand and modernize the nation’s 5th largest Port of Entry. 

Press release: Readout of Deputy Secretary Mayorka’s Visit Texas

2-21-2014

Press Release: Sheriff’s Report on Migrant Killing Raises Concern About Impartiality

2-24-2014

Press Release: The IACHR Expresses Deep Concern Over the Deaths of Migrants Caused by the U.S. Border Patrol

3-10-2014

An off-duty Border Patrol agent from California fatally shot a man in Detroit during a dispute that may have stemmed from a card game. Deputy Chief Rodney Johnson says an argument between the agent’s cousin and another man outside the home and the other man brandished a gun from inside a vehicle. Johnson says the agent fired several shots at the other man, killing him.

Article: Police Off-duty Border Patrol Agent Kills Man

5-30-2014

A review of the released documents reveals that most, if not all, of the PERF recommendations were included in the new Use of Force Handbook. These include new policies that direct agents to do the following:

  • Report all incidents of use of force for the agency to review.
  • Limit use of Electronic Control Weapons (Tasers) to situations in which subject is resisting in a manner that will cause injury;
  • Do not apply more than 3 times or to sensitive areas, or in flammable situations, or to vulnerable populations (children, etc.).
  • Do not shoot at moving vehicles unless imminent threat of serious injury or death; Do not shoot at fleeing vehicles; Do not place yourself in the path of moving vehicle.
  • Do not shoot in response to projectiles unless there is danger of serious death or injury; Seek cover or remove yourself from area of danger.

Press Release: Release of PERF Report and Revised Use-of-Force Policies a Victory for Southern Border Communities

5-30-2014

Jose Luis Arambula was shot and killed in Green Valley, Arizona as he was fleeing Border Patrol agents. Border Patrol Agent Daniel Marquez fired multiple shots at Arambula, killing him.

Article: U.S. Citizen shot 9 times in the back by border patrol agent hours after PERF report and revised use-of-force policies were released. 

6-9-2014

“The head of internal affairs for U.S. Customs and Border Protection was removed from his post Monday amid criticism that he failed to investigate hundreds of allegations of abuse and use of force by armed border agents, officials said.”

Records released last month showed that only 13 out of 809 abuse complaints sent to Customs and Border Protection’s office of internal affairs between January 2009 and January 2012 led to disciplinary action.

Article: Los Angeles Times: Border agency ousts head of internal affairs, will investigate unit.

7-1-2014

US federal court ruled that even though 15-year-old Sergio Adrian Hernandez Guereca was on Mexican soil when he was shot, he was protected by US Constitution. “…the fifth circuit helped ensure that CBP agents are held accountable for shocking and outrageous abuse, even when their victims aren’t inside the US … The fifth circuit clearly signaled that Border Patrol cannot operate with impunity.”

Article: Mexican Teenager killed by US Border Patrol agents had rights, court rules.

7-29-2014

Mother of Slain Mexican Teen Sues U.S. Border Patrol Agents, Seeks Trial in Shooting Death of Her Son

Click here for a copy of the complaint filed in Rodriguez v. John Does.

9-18-2014

The U.S. border patrol will begin wearing cameras at its training academy . R Gil Kerlikowske announced the plans on September 16 that testing will occur at the border patrol academy in Artesia, New Mexico.

Article: US border patrol to begin testing body-worn cameras for field use

10-7-2014

A federal judge in San Diego ruled that a civil case brought by the relatives of Anastasio Hernandez Rojas, a man who died after being beaten and shot with a Taser by a U.S. border agents, can go to trial. The judge ruled against the agents’ request for summary judgment in the case, saying valid questions of constitutional rights were at stake.

Press Release: Case of San Diego Father Beaten to Death by Border Agents Advances to Trial
Article: Judge Clears Way For Trial Of Border Agents Over Taser Death

10-24-2014

Amaro Lopez died with a single gunshot to the head, according to Pima County Medical Examiner’s Office. Two BP agents were after several men in the area of West Hermans and South Sandario when one of the men tried to shoot one of the agents. One agent fired his weapon in response. The other members of the group ran off.

Article: Man Killed in Border Patrol Shooting was Mexican

Speak Your Mind

*